Do we respect ourselves as Women?
By Reeti Roy
A discussion in class today sparked these thoughts. We were in the middle of a Film Studies class when a professor that I have immense respect and admiration for began to talk about the School of Subaltern Studies. He was talking about Robinson Crusoe and he started talking about how the story is quite simple- how it is about a man trapped on an island and his adventures on that island. However, for the longest time,no one really thought of Robinson Crusoe as a manifesto of Colonialism.
Colonialism in Robinson Crusoe was thus not only naturalized but also legitimized as a Social Worldview as though it would make things better.
The more I thought about this today, the clearer things became to me. How many of us really respect ourselves as women? How many of us question patriarchy? How many of us refuse to suffer silently and speak up?
I have an example for this too. Most of my friends have at some point or the other been sexually abused. And nine times out of ten, it has been a relative who has abused them. Most of these girls would not dare to speak out about this in public. Some of them even said they had feelings of guilt. When I was abused as a sixteen year old schoolgirl (about four years ago) I had feelings of guilt. Had I dressed too provocatively? What had prompted such action? Why had I been meted out this kind of treatment? These were the questions that I asked myself, little realizing that this was the effect of years of brainwashing- an effort to make a woman feel inferior and subservient in a patriarchy. I didn't tell myself that no manner what I wore, no one had the right to even touch me without my permission.
What about forced marriages where women are burnt alive if their families cannot pay dowry? In urban India, dowries are often masked as "gifts". What happens then? Do we not have the right to choose our partners?
Before these heinous acts are eradicated, we must learn to stand up for ourselves. The truth of the matter is that as women we have become accustomed to the naturalized and legitimized worldview. We should learn to stand up for ourselves first.
A discussion in class today sparked these thoughts. We were in the middle of a Film Studies class when a professor that I have immense respect and admiration for began to talk about the School of Subaltern Studies. He was talking about Robinson Crusoe and he started talking about how the story is quite simple- how it is about a man trapped on an island and his adventures on that island. However, for the longest time,no one really thought of Robinson Crusoe as a manifesto of Colonialism.
Colonialism in Robinson Crusoe was thus not only naturalized but also legitimized as a Social Worldview as though it would make things better.
The more I thought about this today, the clearer things became to me. How many of us really respect ourselves as women? How many of us question patriarchy? How many of us refuse to suffer silently and speak up?
I have an example for this too. Most of my friends have at some point or the other been sexually abused. And nine times out of ten, it has been a relative who has abused them. Most of these girls would not dare to speak out about this in public. Some of them even said they had feelings of guilt. When I was abused as a sixteen year old schoolgirl (about four years ago) I had feelings of guilt. Had I dressed too provocatively? What had prompted such action? Why had I been meted out this kind of treatment? These were the questions that I asked myself, little realizing that this was the effect of years of brainwashing- an effort to make a woman feel inferior and subservient in a patriarchy. I didn't tell myself that no manner what I wore, no one had the right to even touch me without my permission.
What about forced marriages where women are burnt alive if their families cannot pay dowry? In urban India, dowries are often masked as "gifts". What happens then? Do we not have the right to choose our partners?
Before these heinous acts are eradicated, we must learn to stand up for ourselves. The truth of the matter is that as women we have become accustomed to the naturalized and legitimized worldview. We should learn to stand up for ourselves first.


13 Comments:
Hear hear!!
By
Anonymous, At
January 19, 2009 at 9:08 AM
'We should learn to stand up for ourselves first. ' How true! And as parents of the next generation - I think all of us have to make a conscious effort to make sure that we pass this on to our daughters - that they need to stand up for themselves - and that we will be with them!
By
Smitha, At
January 19, 2009 at 9:53 AM
"Never lose your individuality" was my mother's constant advice.. never used to understand it fully during the growing up years.. but somehow it got stuck in the subconscious mind and has made me stand up for my rights even if it was not easy at times.
As Smitha said, as parents we need to make our daughters strong to face this world that sometimes cannot stand to face a strong one.
By
Happy Kitten, At
January 20, 2009 at 3:34 AM
wonderful post. But we HAVE to learn that it is as, if not more, important to teach boy children how to conduct themselves and respect girls. An encouragement to violence against women starts at a very young age and parents are to blame for making excuses. Gender bias is NOT just a women's issue.
By
sc, At
January 20, 2009 at 3:37 AM
women are coming up stronger now, specially in the indian metros, the working women, these things are heard of very rare.
BPO work from home
By
workhard, At
January 20, 2009 at 11:19 AM
I read the post today and I too was reminded of my college days when we were studying 'Subaltern Studies'.And I learnt how women still remained confined to the margins,how even 'historical'and'written documents' were also self -conscious products of those who were in power.....more things are coming to mind.and the space is limited...but this especially stayed with me..
Uma Chakravarti says ,with regard to ‘Subaltern Studies’,’’It is ironical that even as a certain space was opening up for a history of the ‘powerless’,the most powerless among the powerless remained outside the framework of new historical trends.’’
Also a quote comes to mind ,Gloria Steinem's
''We've begun to raise daughters more like sons... but few have the courage to raise our sons more like our daughters. ''
If only...
By
Indyeah, At
January 20, 2009 at 2:33 PM
sadly the thing is reeti that if women speak out, they're snubbed. so yes, it is brainwashing under fear.
By
roopscoop, At
January 21, 2009 at 2:56 PM
Wow, brilliant writing. Appreciate.
Good site. Keep posting I bookmarked it. not even article but your title itself give touchable mark.
By
Social Network India, At
January 23, 2009 at 12:38 AM
@ anonymous: thank you
@smitha: I wish that more and more mothers would begin to think like you.
@happy kitten: yes, you make a very pertinent point :)
@sc: thank you :)
@indyeah: I agree with everything you say :)
@roop: yes, exactly. I wish more and more people would be allowed to "question the questions", as Shashi Tharoor had once said.
@social networking India: Thank you
By
Reeti, At
January 23, 2009 at 4:55 AM
I guess it's important to remember that there is resistance everywhere, regardless of the minority...?
I do think, however, think that it must be so darn tough for the minority/less-powerful (in this case women) who lack so much broader social, cultural, and/or economic support to stand up and resist the dominant paradigm.
I guess at the end of the day, there is a bit of a payoff (social status, old-age security) for women who conform to the broader society (and for example ensure that sons over daughters are born)...
What about the Indian government reduce the defence budget by 10% (which is a HUGE amount of money) in order to funnel it into old age pension programs (so that women can live regardless of whether or not they have a son to support them) as part of the solution?? I only ask, because I think it could form an important part of reversing the skewed sex ratio...
What do y'all think??
By
Nina, At
January 28, 2009 at 7:12 AM
I remember you blog oftenly on because of the content makes very nice to read. Also I got some of the social networking website and online friends community website to get more friends for fun and entertainment to reach right destination about online friends.
Indian Friends Online Community
Social Network website
Make Money Online
By
jaya, At
July 8, 2009 at 1:30 AM
great work to respect the women....nice blog
Work from home
By
raj, At
August 24, 2009 at 1:53 PM
Message………………………
We need your help to spread this empowering message to women and all citizens around. There are millions of women from all over the world who need encouragement and the truth that they are worthy and remarkable. One small act of kindness on your part can cause a ripple that reaches thousands of women everywhere.
Kartar Aasra Old age Orphanage Home
Your mother was someone’s daughter
Still want to send your girl to slaughter?
Give the girl child an opportunity to make her parents proud.
Don’t kill her
Join hands, turn the tide
Say ‘NO’ to female infanticide.
Drop them at our newly installed Cradle (Pungura) at Kartar Aasra Entrance.
http://www.kartaraasra.org/ +91 9878888838
By
Kartar Aasra Trust, At
January 14, 2012 at 11:14 AM
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home